Return to Magic, Medicine and Science
homepage
Return to Magic, Medicine and Science
syllabus
Plotinus' Metaphysics
1. The three hypostases:
The One
ineffable, transcendent
Intellect
The Realm of Being (contains the Platonic Forms)
Soul
contains the seminal reasons
The Physical World of Becoming
2. The One.
Plato's the Good. Ineffable, transcendent, perfect; knowable only
through what it is not.
3. Intellect.
The Realm of Being; the Realm of the Forms/Ideas. A
"One-in-Many":
the Forms are the thoughts of the Intellect; in thinking them, they are
given being. Aristotle's Prime Mover (self-thinking
thought).
Eternity is the mode of existence of Intellect.
4. Soul.
Immanent in the physical world of Becoming, but transcendent to
it.
The "higher" part of Soul contemplates Intellect. The "lower"
part
generates the Physical World guided by the seminal
reasons (logoi spermatikoi). A "One-and-Many".
Three
distinctions: Soul, World Soul, individual souls; the latter two
are aspects of the former. Time is the "life" of the Soul.
(a) World Soul: the physical cosmos has a soul and is
thus
a living organism (see, eg, Timaeus).
(b) Individual souls. Composed of two parts: one
remains
in the realm of Intellect (the "higher" part of Soul), the other
descends
to inhabit a coporeal body in the physical world. Hence humans
are
directly connected to the One via the Intellect. Individuals are
the link between the realms. Humans as amphibians.
Note: The Stoics held individual souls are fragments of the
World
Soul. For Plotinus, both are on equal footing as aspects of
Soul.
(The Stoic cosmos might be characterized as consistiing of just the
third
hypostasis: Soul. The mediator is air (pneuma).
See Ficino, later.)
Problems:
-
What is the distinction between the "higher" aspect of Soul and
Intellect?
Soul is that aspect of Intellect which "falls"?
-
What is the relation between an individual soul and the corporeal body
it "inhabits"?
-
Plato: The body as an instrument (and a prison) for the
soul.
The soul is immaterial and immortal: exists before and after the body.
-
Aristotle: The soul is the immaterial Form and the
body
is the Matter. An individual = soul + body = form + matter.
-
Plotinus: An individual = soul + body, but body
itself
consists of matter and form. Hence 3 distinctions: soul1,
soul2, body. Soul2,
the form of the body, is a part of the World-Soul. Soul1
(the individual soul) is immaterial and immortal and linked with the
Intellect.
Note, however, that such disctinctions begin to blur when stress is
placed
on the fact that both the World-Soul and individual souls are aspects
of
one and the same Soul.
5. The Physical World. Soul creates the objects of
the
physical world by imparting the Forms in the Intellect onto matter by
means
of the seminal reasons. Bare matter occupies the lowest level in
the Plotonian hierarchy. It is the source of evil.
6. The two-act theory
and
the doctrine of procession/reversion: Plotinus’ solution
to the problem of the one and the many.
-
Two aspects to all things: an "inner act" and an "outer
act".
The inner act is the substance or essence of the thing. The outer
act is a distinct entity; an image or likeness of the inner act.
Example: Heat as the essence of fire (its inner act) vs heat
that flows out (emmanates/procedes) from fire (its outer act).
- Each hypostasis is the complete cause of the next lower
one. The
lower one emmanates (“procedes”) from the higher as the outer act of
the
higher. This accounts only for the existence or "matter" of the
lower
level. This matter is then informed, and the lower hypostasis
comes
into being, through the act of contemplating ("reverting" back
to)
the higher one. Characteristics: Procession and reversion
are
non-temporal events. Procession is necessary, undeliberate and
undiminishing.
7. The dynamics of Plotinus’ metaphysics:
-
Intellect procedes necessarily from, and without diminish to, the One
(the
One is perfect; that which is perfect reproduces itself).
Intellect
contemplates the One and brings itself and the Forms into being; the
Forms
are the representation in the Intellect of the One produced in the act
of reversion.
-
Soul procedes necessarily from, and without diminish to, the
Intellect.
Soul contemplates the Intellect and brings itself and the seminal
reasons
into being.
-
The Physical World emmanates from Soul with the seminal reasons
directing
the participation of physical objects in the Forms.
8. Mystical union with
the One. Individual souls have become separated from the
One (God): reverence for earthy things and lack of respect for
themselves
are the causes. They can regain their connection with the
Intellect
and the One, and hence their true natures, by being reminded of their
parentage.
To do so, we must turn inwards.