Attorney General Ashcroft Testifies Before Congress
About the Patriot Act
Prepared remarks before the House of Representatives
Committee on the Judiciary
June 5, 2003
ATTORNEY GENERAL ASHCROFT: During Operation Enduring Freedom,
on the wind-swept plateaus of Afghanistan, some American military
commanders read a list every morning to their troops - names
of the men and women who died on September 11. It was a stark
reminder of why they were there.
Joseph Maffeo
Diana M. Hale-McKinzy
Susan Ann Ruggiero
Manny Del Valle
Wanda Prince
Charles E. Sabin ?
To read every name of every victim who died at the hands
of terrorists on September 11 would take three hours. To read
all the names of sons and daughters, wives and husbands, friends
and family affected by the loss of loved ones on that tragic
day would be impossible.
I come before this Committee having not forgotten the promise
made to those stolen from us by terrorism?s ideology of hate.
The roots of this murderous ideology can be found in this
1998 fatwa issued by al Qaeda?s founders, Osama bin Laden
and Ayman Al-Zawahiri, declaring war on American civilians.
In it, they write, quote, ?The judgment to kill Americans
and their allies, both civilian and military, is the individual
duty of every Muslim able to do so, and in any country where
it is possible.? And, ?We in the name of God, call on every
Muslim who believes in God and desires to be rewarded, to
follow God?s order to kill Americans and plunder their wealth
wherever and whenever they find it.? On September 11, bloodthirsty
terrorists answered Bin Laden?s call for killing.
Twenty months ago President Bush pledged that al Qaeda and
the terrorist network would not escape the patient justice
of the United States - for we would remember the victims of
terrorism.
Today, brave men and women in uniform abroad and at home
answer our President?s call for justice. Sworn to defend the
Constitution and our liberties, and motivated by the memories
of September 11, they live each day by a code of honor, duty,
and country. And they know that they may die preserving the
promise that terrorism will not reach this land of liberty
again - for we are a nation locked in a deadly war with the
evil of terrorism.
We will not forget that in Afghanistan, on the dusty road
to Kandahar, Army Sgt. Orlando Morales was killed on reconnaissance
patrol 70 in a town called Geresk. He leaves behind a wife
and 17-month-old daughter. Sergeant Morales was in Afghanistan
fighting to destroy the Taliban regime, terrorist operatives,
and their training camps.
His sacrifice was not in vain. In this war, over half of
al Qaeda?s senior operatives have been captured or killed.
Some of those captured were operatives, like Khalid Shaik
Mohammed. Others, like military commander Mohammed Atef, are
silenced forever. Overall, more than 3,000 foot soldiers of
terror have been incapacitated.
We will not forget that in the battles in Iraq, Marine Lance
Corporal David Fribley of Warsaw, Indiana, was killed near
Nasiriyah by Iraqi soldiers who pretended to surrender - but
then opened fire. Lance Corporal Fribley made the ultimate
sacrifice to free the Iraqi people and to eliminate a key
sponsor of terror.
We must not forget that this great fight for freedom
did not end in Kabul. It will not end along the banks of the
Tigris and Euphrates. The fight continues here - on America?s
streets, off our shores, and in the skies above.
Americans do not shy from danger or turn away from threats
to liberty. On September 11, we saw our nation's finest ideals
in action. Firefighters and police officers rushed to - not
from - the World Trade Center. We saw Americans embrace duty,
face danger, and sacrifice their lives for their fellow citizens
and for freedom.
On that tragic day, 343 firefighters and 71 police officers
died in the line of duty. Today, the Justice Department, agents
of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, as well as state and
local law enforcement officers, uphold the legacy of our fallen
heroes.
From state troopers on the roads to cops on the beat, from
intelligence analysts to FBI field agents, these are the sentinels
serving with silent determination to protect America's citizens.
They wage this defense with the tools you help provide them.
Twenty months ago, you understood what was needed to preserve
freedom. You understood that our nation?s success in this
long war on terrorism demanded that the Justice Department
continuously adapt and improve its capabilities to protect
Americans from a fanatical, ruthless enemy.
That is why you worked with us to shape an anti-terrorism
law housed in the framework of American freedom - the Constitution
of the United States.
Congress overwhelmingly approved the USA PATRIOT Act. In
the House, Representatives voted 357 to 66 for the measure,
while the Senate supported the legislation by a near unanimous
98-to-1 vote.
The PATRIOT Act gave us the tools we needed to integrate
our law enforcement and intelligence capabilities to win the
war on terror.
It allowed the Department of Justice to use the same tools
from the criminal process on terrorists that we use to combat
mobsters or drug dealers. We use these tools to gather intelligence
and to prevent terrorists from unleashing more death and destruction
within our country. We use these tools to connect the ?dots.?
We use these tools to save innocent lives.
The ?Buffalo Cell? case shows how the PATRIOT Act and the
criminal process can drive intelligence gathering. There,
we learned of information about individuals who allegedly
trained in an al Qaeda camp in Afghanistan and lived in the
United States.
The Department used confidential informants to gather facts;
we used subpoenas to collect travel information to track their
movements; we deployed surveillance to record conversations;
we used search warrants to locate weapons and jihad materials;
and we used some of the best interrogators from the FBI to
obtain critical admissions from some of the defendants.
The Department also used one of the most effective tools
at the government?s disposal - the leverage of criminal charges
and long prison sentences. As is often the case with criminal
defendants, when individuals realize that they face a long
prison term like those under the PATRIOT Act, they will try
to cut their prison time by pleading guilty and cooperating
with the government.
In fact, since September 11, we have obtained criminal plea
agreements, many under seal, from more than 15 individuals,
who must - and will continue to - cooperate with the government
in its terrorist investigations.
These individuals have provided critical intelligence about
al Qaeda and other terrorist groups, safehouses, training
camps, recruitment, and tactics in the U.S., and the operations
of those terrorists who mean to do American citizens harm.
One individual has given us intelligence on weapons stored
here in the United States. Another cooperator has identified
locations in the U.S. being scouted or cased for potential
attacks by al Qaeda.
With the PATRIOT Act and our prevention strategy, we can
point to steady progress in America?s war against terrorism.
We are targeting terrorists here at home, while developing
detailed intelligence on terrorist threats:
· Hundreds of suspected terrorists have been identified and
tracked throughout the U.S., with more than 18,000 subpoenas
and search warrants issued;
· Our human sources of intelligence have doubled, as has
the number of anti-terrorism investigations.
· In 2002, using Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act tools,
we targeted more than 1,000 international terrorists, spies
and foreign powers, who threaten our country?s security. We
requested 170 emergency FISAs. This is more than three-times
the total number of emergency FISAs obtained in the 23 years
prior to September 11.
We are arresting and detaining potential terrorist threats:
· More than a dozen members of alleged terrorist cells in
Buffalo, Seattle, Portland and Detroit, were arrested, along
with more than 100 other individuals who were convicted or
pled guilty to federal crimes as a result of our post-September
11 terrorism investigations;
· On Tuesday, we gained three convictions in the Detroit
Cell case: two on terrorist conspiracy charges and the third
on visa and document fraud charges; and
We are shutting down the terrorist financial infrastructure:
· As a result of 70 investigations into terror?s money trail,
more than $125 million in assets and over 600 accounts were
frozen around the world.
We are building a long-term counter-terrorism capacity with:
· Over 1,000 new and redirected FBI agents dedicated to counter-terrorism
and counter-intelligence;
· 250 new Assistant U.S. Attorneys; and
· 66 Joint Terrorism Task Forces, with a 337 percent increase
in staffing.
Most important, no major terror attack has occurred on American
soil since September 11.
Let me be clear. Al Qaeda is diminished, but not destroyed.
Defeat after defeat has made the terrorists desperate to strike
back.
Bombings in Tel Aviv, Israel, Bali, Indonesia, Casablanca,
Morocco and Riyadh, Saudi Arabia are bitter reminders that
the cold-blooded network of terror will continue to use the
horror of their heinous acts to achieve their fanatical ends.
Innocent American and Saudi citizens died in the Riyadh compounds
last month at the hands of al Qaeda.
We will not forget American Obadiah Abdullah, who converted
to Islam and, after retiring from an 11-year career in the
U.S. Army, took a job that would allow him to make a pilgrimage
to Mecca.
Clifford Lawson retired as an Army staff sergeant in 1997.
He had a talent for computers and electronics, and he loved
his family. He was supposed to return home for his son?s 13th
birthday in July.
Todd Bair also served in the military. Just two weeks before
he was murdered, he returned from a visit with his family.
He was a man of faith, who leaves behind a wife and two sons,
ages 11 and eight.
We must be vigilant and unrelenting. We must not forget that
al Qaeda?s primary terrorist target is the United States.
Even though recent attacks were overseas, the terrorist network
is committed to killing innocent Americans, including women
and children, by the thousands or even the millions if they
can.
Nasir Bin Hamd Al-Fahd is a prominent, extremist Saudi cleric
known to have significant connections to al Qaeda operatives
who seek his religious justification and support for terrorist
operations. Just last month, he issued a new fatwah entitled,
?The Legal Status of Using Weapons of Mass Destruction Against
Infidels? that lays out his religious argument for the use
of weapons of mass destruction against Americans.
I quote, ?Anyone who considers America?s aggressions against
Muslims and their lands during the past decades will conclude
that striking her is permissible ? .?
Al-Fahd asserts, quote, ?The weapons of mass destruction
will kill any of the infidels on whom they fall, regardless
of whether they are fighters, women or children. They will
destroy and burn the land. The arguments for the permissibility
are many.?
Further, Al Fahd, says, ?If a bomb that killed ten million
of them and burned as much of their land as they have burned
Muslims? land were dropped on them, it would be permissible.?
Despite the terrorist threat to America, there are some in
Congress and across the country who suggest that we should
not have a USA PATRIOT Act. Others, who supported the Act
20 months ago, now express doubts about the necessity of some
of the Act?s components.
Let me state this as clearly as possible.
Our ability to prevent another catastrophic attack on American
soil would be more difficult, if not impossible, without the
PATRIOT Act. It has been the key weapon used across America
in successful counter-terrorist operations to protect innocent
Americans from the deadly plans of terrorists.
Unfortunately, the law has several weaknesses which terrorists
could exploit, undermining our defenses.
First, in pursuit of terrorist cells, current law makes it
a crime to provide a terrorist organization with personnel
or training. We must make it crystal clear that those who
train for and fight with a designated terrorist organization
can be charged under material support statutes.
Second, existing law does not consistently encourage cooperation
by providing adequate maximum penalties to punish acts of
terrorism. Some terrorist acts resulting in the death of citizens
do not provide for the death penalty or even life imprisonment.
Third, terrorism offenses are not expressly included in the
list of crimes that allow for pre-trial detention, even though
it could prevent an attack. In criminal cases where public
safety is of concern - such as drug dealing, organized crime,
and gun crimes - defendants in federal cases are presumptively
denied pretrial release.
As we weigh the Constitutional methods we will use to defend
innocent Americans from terrorism, we must not forget the
names that unite us in our cause:
Cherone Gunn
Ronald Scott Owens
Ronchester Santiago
Timothy Saunders
Lakiba Nicole Palmer
These are some of the brave men and women of the USS
Cole who were murdered by al Qaeda in 2000. Weeks ago,
when I met with the families of those who died on the Cole,
they pleaded that we not forget them. I am committed to their
families not being forgotten.
Cherone Gunn had been in the Navy less than a year and loved
serving his country. He wanted to become a law enforcement
officer. Ronchester Santiago planned to study electrical engineering
at the University of Texas.
Ronald Scott Owens left behind his wife, Jamie, and a little
girl named Isabella Marie. Lakiba Palmer died, leaving an
18-month-old daughter who will never know her mother. The
two daughters of Timothy Saunders were ten and seven years
old when they lost their father.
The names I have recalled today all bear silent, painful
witness to the fact that the United States is a nation at
war.
We must never forget that we are in a war to preserve life
and liberty.
We must not forget that our enemies are ruthless fanatics,
who seek to murder innocent men, women and children to achieve
their twisted goals.
We must not forget that in the struggle between the forces
of freedom and the ideology of hate, our challenge in this
war against terrorism is to adapt and anticipate, to out-think
and outmaneuver our enemies, while honoring our Constitution.
The United States Department of Justice has been called to
defend America. We accept that charge.
We fight in the tradition of all great American struggles:
with resolve, defiance, and honor.
We fight to secure victory over the evil in our midst.
We fight to uphold the liberties and ideals that define a
free and brave people.
Every day the Justice Department is working tirelessly, taking
this war to the hideouts and havens of our enemies, so that
it never again touches the hearths and homes of America.
I thank you for the opportunity to testify today. I thank
you for the Constitutional weapons that make the war for freedom
a conflict whose end is not in doubt. And I thank the American
people for their support and faith in the justice of our cause.
I would now be happy to answer your questions.
### |